ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS OF COLLABORATIVE AND PORTFOLIO WRITING TACTICS ON STUDENTS’ PERFORMANCE IN ESSAY WRITING IN SENIOR SECONDARY SCHOOLS, KADUNA STATE, NIGERIA
ABSTRACT
The study investigated the effects of collaborative and portfolio writing strategies on students‟ performance in essay writing in senior secondary schools, Kaduna State, Nigeria. Seven objectives, research questions and hypotheses guided the study. The objectives were to: examine the effect of collaborative and conventional writing strategies, portfolio and conventional, collaborative, portfolio and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in essay writing: also, effect of collaborative, portfolio and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in content, organization and grammatical components of essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State. The study reviewed related literature. The target population of the study was forty nine thousand eight hundred SSII students from the 12 Educational Zones in Kaduna State. The sample size comprised of three hundred and seven SSII students from six intact classes. The study was carried out using quasi –experimental design. The instrument tagged „Essay Writing Performance Test” was used for data collection in the study. The instrument, after being validated by specialists in English Language and curriculum specialists was pilot-tested using a test and re-test method. The reliability index of 0.75 was gotten thereafter. Data for the study was collected through the administration of pre-test and post-test. The demographic data of the respondents were analyzed using descriptive statistics which involved frequencies and percentages while mean and standard deviation were used to analyze responses to research questions whilet-test and Analysis of Covariance were also used to test the hypotheses at 0.05 alpha level of significance.Findings from the study revealed that students taught essay writing using collaborative writing strategy performed significantly better than those taught using conventional writing strategy (p-value .000 <0.05); there was no significant difference in the performance of students taught essay writing using portfolio and conventional writing strategies ( p-value .587> 0.05); the performance of students taught essay writing using collaborative writing strategy was significantly better than those taught using portfolio writing strategy (p-value .000< 0.05); students taught essay writing using collaborative writing strategy had a significantly better performance than those taught using portfolio and conventional writing strategies (p-value .000< 0.05); and students taught essay writing using collaborative writing strategy performed significantly better in content, organization and grammatical components of their writing than those taught using portfolio and conventional writing strategies. Based on the findings, it was recommended among others that collaborative writing strategy should be adopted and promoted by teachers and stakeholders for teaching essay writing in senior secondary schools. Listening, reading and speaking skills can be enhanced using collaborative and portfolio writing strategies. Furthermore, collaborative writing strategy can be used to manage large essay writing classes.
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background to the Study
English is undoubtedly the most important language which is being employed for communication purposes across the globe (Akinwamide, 2012). The use of English as a tool for effective communication, study and work, as well as an important goal of secondary education is advocated in the national policy on education (FRN, 2013). The crucial role English Language plays in the Nigerian linguistic scene makes it imperative for Nigerians to show evidence of reasonable degree of competence and of more vigorous training in its use, than in the use of any other foreign language. Muodumogu and Unwaha (2013), state that English language is a recognized medium of communication in the administration of government businesses in Nigeria. It is also the medium of instruction through which learners acquire knowledge and skills at all levels of education. However, in spite of the vital roles of the English language, most Nigerians are unable to acquire mastery in the skills of the language especially writing. Consequent upon this, there is a need to orientate quality of instruction towards utilizing competencies and essay writing skills for self- reliance and development of the society.
The poor performance of students in national examinations both in English language and other subjects has been attributed to poor language teaching and learning (Okonkwo, 2015; Saad & Usman, 2014). The mastery of writing skills is crucial since constant evaluation either formative or summative is conducted to gauge students‟ acquisition of their writing skills based on their writing performance. Hence teachers adopt and adapt various strategies in the essay writing classrooms to ensure that students excel in writing. But from the existing situation of poor and low performance of students in essay writing, one can conclude that the approaches or strategies used may be faulty at one level or the other. This presupposes that more researches need to be carried out to ascertain this claim.
Teaching essay writing is usually approached with apprehension by many teachers and students because it demands the knowledge of many skills such as grammar, style syntax and semantics in one lesson (Okonkwo, 2015). Writing is a basic tool for secondary education in Nigeria and many other parts of the world. Writing does not come naturally as speaking but it is an activity that students and teachers cannot run away from. It must be consciously learnt and developed for it is one of the critical skills a student develops in high school.
The inspiration for this study arose from the fact that over the years, there has been persistent rate of low performance of students in English language, especially essay writing. Students are unable to write effectively (Komolafe &Yara, 2010). This situation is not peculiar to any level, but it is more pronounced and disturbing at the secondary level because certificates are required for higher education at this level
. The trend of general poor performance in English language is not peculiar to Nigerian students and schools alone. It is a worldwide phenomenon existing even in developed countries like America. Harwood in Alao (2011) complained about the poor mastery of essay writing skills in America. This situation pervades all levels of Nigeria‟s educational ladder-primary, secondary and the post-secondary institutions. The reports of Grieves and Banjo were attempts by the Nigerian government to find how best to improve the teaching of English language and enhance essay writing skills. Despite these efforts, the skills of students in essay writing have not shown any improvement. Hence, there is need for rigorous training.
West African Examination Council (WAEC) Chief Examiner‟s Report (2009) lists poor knowledge of the rules of grammar, inability to construct good sentences, lack of teachers‟ exposure to modern strategies of teaching as causes of students‟ poor achievement in English. Adeosun (2006: 4) lamented the inability of students to write good compositions, noting:
“Composition tests are designed to test the candidates‟ ability to use English as effective means of communication in a given situation, the ability to express oneself with clarity and coherence in a manner appropriate to the audience, purpose, topic situation, adding that most students lack variety of skills, good grasp and knowledge of basic language skills which they are expected to know effectively”
Essay writing is taught at secondary level to enable students develop writing skills to cope with their academic work, as well as develop type of writing needed both inside and outside the school situation. Students at this level depend to a large degree on extended writing skills in examinations (Adeyemi, 2012). Essay writing refers to continuous writing produced in form of any of the following: letters, speeches, articles, descriptive, persuasive, narrative and expository compositions. Increasingly, students are required to demonstrate proficiency in essay writing through planning, writing and revising an essay, summary, note taking in groups and so forth. This study seeks to explore more modern strategies that would help provide a valuable head start to improve students essay writing thereby resulting into better grades in English especially at the senior secondary level.
Essay writing involves more than just being able to compose correct sentences; it also involves the ability to use the lexical item appropriately in acts of communication to achieve communication ends (Akagu, in Alao, 2011).Evidence from students‟ WAEC scripts in various subjects, shows that the skill and abilities that students need in writing, must be formally taught in order to perform the writing demands of their various subjects with some ease and some confidence. Essay writing among these students therefore deserves attention more than any other aspects of language especially at the senior secondary school, which is the target of this study. This is because there is need to prepare the students for the various writing tasks, which they would meet in their future academic pursuits.
Essay writing sub-skills are content, organization, expression and mechanical accuracy. These are four basic elements that collectively determine the quality of essay writing as assessed by WAEC and other examination bodies in Nigeria. The innovations in English language teaching has led to the change in the strategy of teaching writing from the traditional way of end product-oriented approach to the process of creating writing (Tabatabaei & Assefi, 2012). In Nigerian secondary schools, most teachers have been using the product approach which focuses on the end product of writing undertaken under severe pressure and this seems not to have achieved much success. One wonders whether the methods employed are not proper. This study would examine whether the use of collaborative writing and portfolio writing strategies could be used to advance essay writing pedagogy.
The teaching of essay writing should take the communication approach that aims at helping the learners to manipulate language structures effectively since the essence of language is for communication. Adeyemi (2012) posited that in process approach, students are guided to plan, draft and revise their writing and are also encouraged “to learn to write” as opposed to “writing to learn”. This would facilitate their ability to form clear and correct concepts through the use of language to express their feelings, needs, ideas, knowledge and interests with exactness and precision. This is why Ogbu (2009) indicate that writing, which could be seen as the ability to produce correct forms of words and sentences is a very important skill of language acquisition. This study would examine a communicative and interactive approach that would help learners manipulate language structures effectively.
Collaborative writing strategy (CWS) is an instruction strategy that makes use of small, heterogeneous groups of students who work together to achieve common learning goals. It is a task-centred activity requiring students-to-students interaction in small groups as the structures and contents are organized and sequenced in essay writing. Individuals are responsible for their actions which include learning, respect and contributions among their peers. They extend their critical thinking and reasoning skills, which help in understanding of social interactions as they become involved, and take control of the learning process through collaborative activities (Nwakonobi & Obiagwu, 2013). It is a strategy which has been proven to culminate positive results and outcomes (Tengku Nor Rizan, 2007). Collaborative writing between and among students should be trial-tested to see how effective they are in generating healthy discussion, and learning which encourage an effective process of essay writing.
Portfolio writing strategy (PWS) is seen as “a cumulative and on-going collection of entries that are selected and commented on by the student, the teacher and or peers, to assess the students‟ progress in the development of a competency” (Simon & Forgette-Giroux in Alti 2009). In the view of Taki and Heidari (2010), portfolio is the assessment of some data about students‟ skills in one or more areas in a certain time period, regular collection of his studies and performances according to predetermined criteria. It is a systematic collection of students‟ written work measured against pre-determined scoring criteria (O‟malley &Valders in Alti, 2009). It is a purposeful collection of essay writing materials over a period of time that can communicate students‟ interests, abilities and achievements in certain areas. According to Fattaneh, Mohsen and Maedeh (2010), portfolio is an effective instructional strategy as well as assessment tool which can be used to encourage and motivate weak writers. Thus, in this study, portfolio is described as a systematic and purposeful collection of students‟ drafts which reflect the success, performance, and efforts of the students in one more areas of essay writing over a period of time.
The mastery of essay writing skills is crucial since constant evaluation either formative or summative is conducted to gauge students‟ acquisition of their writing skills based on their writing performance (Okonkwo, 2014).In view of the present ineffectiveness in the writing of students, the inability of the previous approaches to cater for the shortfall in writing pedagogy and the fact that writing has been a neglected area of English language teaching for some years (Siddique & Singh, 2016 ), the need for sound writing research now is greater than ever. The need for this research cannot be over-emphasized. There is therefore the need to undertake a research of this nature in order to explore modern strategies to the teaching of essay writing. It is against this background that this study sought to investigate the effects of collaborative and portfolio writing strategies on essay writing of senior secondary school students in Kaduna State, Nigeria.
1.2 Statement of the Problem
There has been general outcry on the low performance of students in essay writing. Inability of senior secondary students to write and communicate effectively in both written and spoken English based on their inability to use correct grammatical structures and present ideas in a systematic and appropriate manner gives parents, teachers, examination bodies and even students a lot of concern. Annual results from WAEC and the Chief Examiners‟ Reports for 2010 and 2011 reveal woeful performance of students who have made enrolment for English language examination a yearly ritual. The researcher‟s participation in examining WAEC and
NECO candidates for many years also corroborated this low performance of students in essay writing. It is worrisome to note too, that the performance of these students have continued to deteriorate each year.
Many factors have been adduced for students‟ inability to write effectively at the secondary level. These include use of inappropriate teaching methods and approaches. Many strategies have been used in teaching and learning essay writing, yet students‟ performance is low. Writing is taught as a product with heavy emphasis on mechanical accuracy and the final product of writing. Khan, Javaid & Farooq (2015) view such classes as usually dull and as such, teachers and students view writing as an uphill task. Students are just given topics to write on by teachers and marks are awarded accordingly without teachers‟ interest in the process of what went into the production of the essay.
Another problem is the inability of students to write composition that would clearly express their thoughts or ideas in such a way that all the various components of writing- content, organization, grammar, mechanics and objectives of writing would be integrated. Trotman (2010) sees writing as fundamental to success in academics, in the workplace and in the global economy. The ability to write well, hitherto a luxury is now a dire necessity. In the light of this, teaching learners to write well should be uppermost in a worthwhile educational system.
Teachers of English language have expressed preference for teaching certain aspects of the English language syllabus of which essay writing is not one. Many students have little practice in writing essays (Adeyemi, 2012) because their teachers rarely ask them to write because the teachers judge the exercise as laborious coupled with large classes. Teachers are mandated by the educational authorities to follow strictly the National Curriculum, which does not specify especially how the content is to be taught. This practice has granted teachers enough freedom to adopt whatever strategies they like. The current practices disregard the fact that writing is an interactive activity which presupposes that learners need to know who they are interacting with and why.
Considering the need to improve senior secondary students essay writing skill, it becomes necessary to explore alternative strategies of teaching essay writing. The researcher believes that if modern interactive, collaborative and participatory strategies are employed and properly implemented, this can lead to increased motivation and more positive attitude for students towards students‟ essay writing tasks. This can invariably improve students‟ performance in essay writing. This study therefore investigated the effects of collaborative and portfolio writing strategies on students‟ essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria.
1.3 Objectives of the Study
The main focus of this study was to evaluate the effects of collaborative and portfolio writing strategies on the performance of students in essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna States. In specific terms, the study sought to:
- examine the effect of collaborative and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria;
- find out the effect of portfolio and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria;
- determine the effect of collaborative and portfolio writing strategies on students‟ performance essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria;
- investigate the effect of collaborative, portfolio and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria;
- ascertain the effect of collaborative, portfolio and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in content of essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna
State, Nigeria;
- examine the effect of collaborative, portfolio and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in organization of essay writing in senior secondary schools in
Kaduna State, Nigeria; and
- determine the effect of collaborative, portfolio and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in grammatical components of essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria.
1.4 Research Questions
The study was guided by the following research questions:
- What is the effect of collaborative and conventional writing strategies on students‟
performance in essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria?
- To what extent doportfolio and conventional writing strategies have effect on students‟ performance in essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria?
- What is the effect of collaborative and portfolio writing strategies on students‟ performance in essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria?
- To what extent do collaborative, portfolio and conventional writing strategies have effect on students‟ performance in essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria?
- What is the effect of collaborative, portfolio and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in content of essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria?
- To what extent do collaborative, portfolio and conventional writing strategies have effect on students‟ performance in organization of essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria?
- What is the effect of collaborative, portfolio and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in grammatical components of essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria?
1.5 Research Hypotheses
The following null hypotheses were postulated for this study:
HO1 There is no significant difference in the effect of collaborative and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria.
HO2 There is no significant difference in the effect of portfolio and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria.
HO3 There is no significant difference in the effect of collaborative and portfolio writing strategies on students‟ performance in essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria.
| HO4 | There is no significant difference in the effect of collaborative, portfolio and |
| conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance inessay writing in senior | |
| secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria. | |
| HO5 | There is no significant difference in the effect of collaborative, portfolio and |
| conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance in content of essay | |
| writing of in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria. | |
| HO6 | There is no significant difference in the effect of collaborative, portfolio and |
| conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance inorganization of essay writing |
in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria.
HO7 There is no significant difference in the effect of collaborative, portfolio and conventional writing strategies on students‟ performance ingrammatical components of essay writing in senior secondary schools in Kaduna State, Nigeria.
1.6 Significance of the Study
The need to advance the writing pedagogy using new and innovative strategies has been a subject of research to English language specialists. Also, evidence abounds in literature that there seemed to be a dearth of research on students‟ writing. Thus, this study is considered significant
in many ways and will be of immense value to teachers of English language, curriculum planners, examination bodies, textbook writers, educational administrators, students, possibly parents and future researchers.
It is believed that the findings of this study will be of utmost significance to teachers of
English who will be in a better position to guide students toward producing better written essays using the process based strategies. Essay writing, which is the main focus of this study, has not been properly taught at the primary and junior secondary school levels hence the problems students face at the senior secondary level. The result will help writing teachers to identify the strategythat is more effective between collaborative and portfolio writing strategies since the two strategies demonstrate a shift from the product oriented type of teaching to process approach thereby injecting new dimension into writing pedagogy for improved performance in essay writing at both internal and external examinations. This might also be useful to other subject specialists who could adapt the study for their teaching.
Teachers of English will use the findings of this study to foster collaboration among students during and after lessons. In addition, teachers will be able to identify their shortcomings and inadequacies and thereby improve on the strategy and quality of teaching. This could translate into improved essay writing performance if any of the strategies used in this study is found effective and adopted by stakeholders. This could also lead to improved scores in essay writing and better grades in English. Problems of anxiety and apprehension faced by students when faced with essay writing tasks might be reduced based on the activities therein.
Also, curriculum developers could benefit from the result of this research in selection of content, methodologies and materials that would support the use of interactive process-based strategies for teaching essay writing. Activities of interactive, collaborative and portfolio writing strategies could be included in the curriculum to enrich it for better quality of teaching and mastery of essay writing in secondary school English language contexts. This might in turn enhance the performance of essay writing through the use of appropriate teaching strategies.
Examination bodies like WAEC, NECO and so on will also benefit from the result of this present study because the study will likely re-direct their attention to the strengths of CWS and PWS thereby designing tests that assess essay writing in an interactive way. Assessment of essay writing could be designed to take cognizance of both the formative and summative forms. Findings from this study will be of immense value to textbook writers to produce books and materials that would foster interactivity and cooperation among students groups in essay writing and thereby enhance their writing performance. Group activities could be given priority in textbooks and teaching modules.
Researchers in the field of writing will find this study useful as the findings of the research could also advance available literature on writing and essay writing in particular. Scholars in the field will also benefit as the strengths and weaknesses of strategies examined in this study would be documented. It will provide additional information about the procedure employed in using the two strategies of teaching essay writing in the Nigerian context as opposed to their use elsewhere.
Moreover, the suggestions at the end of this study will be useful in improving the performance of students writing especially in the area of content, organization, grammar and mechanics. The skills acquired by the students will make them have better grades and greater academic achievement. Use of these strategies will enable students to develop more confidence and better attitude to essay writing.
1.8 Scope of the Study
The main thrust of this study was to investigate the effects of collaborative and portfolio writing strategies on essay writing of senior secondary school students in Kaduna State, Nigeria. Thus, this study wasdelimited to two teaching strategies namely: Collaborative and portfolio writing and essay writing component of the senior secondary school English curriculum. This aspect of English is viewed as one that indicates the extent to which a student is proficient in the written language.
The subjects of this study were SSII students of Government SecondarySchool, Bomo,
Government Secondary School, Kwangila, Government Secondary School, Hunkuyi,
Government Secondary School, Dakace, Government Secondary School, Gyallesu and Government Secondary School, Tudun Jukun. These schools were sampled because they enroll students from diverse cultural backgrounds but with similar educational backgrounds. This research while using the collaborative writing and portfolio writing strategies to teach essay writing focused on content, organization, grammatical component and mechanical accuracy as sub-skills. This is because these aspects form part of the areas that are usually assessed in both internal and external examinations at the senior secondary level in Nigeria.
ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS OF COLLABORATIVE AND PORTFOLIO WRITING TACTICS ON STUDENTS’ PERFORMANCE IN ESSAY WRITING IN SENIOR SECONDARY SCHOOLS, KADUNA STATE, NIGERIA